Former NYPD Sergeant Released on Bail During Manslaughter Appeal in Bronx Scooter Death

A New York state appellate judge has ordered the release of former New York City police sergeant Erik Duran on bail as he appeals his manslaughter conviction in the 2023 death of Eric Duprey in the Bronx.

Duran, 38, had been sentenced last week to three to nine years in prison for the incident, which occurred during a police anti-narcotics operation on August 23, 2023. According to authorities, Duran threw a picnic cooler at Duprey, 30, as he attempted to flee on a motorized scooter after an alleged drug transaction with police. The cooler struck Duprey, causing him to lose control and crash into a tree. Prosecutors stated Duprey, who was not wearing a helmet, died at the scene from fatal head injuries.

The decision to grant bail came from Judge Saliann Scarpulla of the state’s Appellate Division, who set bail at $300,000 cash or bond and required Duran to surrender his passport to his lawyers. Duran, described as the first former NYPD officer in at least two decades to be sentenced to prison for an on-duty death, had been held at Rikers Island since his sentencing. His lawyers argued that he does not pose a flight risk or danger to the community and that there are substantial issues to be considered in his appeal.

Duran’s release has drawn strong responses from both supporters and critics. Vincent Vallelong, president of the Sergeants Benevolent Association, praised the ruling as a significant victory for Duran and for law enforcement generally. However, the family of Duprey, through their attorney Jon Roberts, expressed disappointment, saying the decision has reopened painful wounds for loved ones who are still seeking accountability.

Public reaction to the case remains divided. The New York Islanders hockey team recently promoted a legal defense fundraiser for Duran during a game, prompting criticism from Duprey’s family, who argued the team’s gesture risked undermining public trust in the justice process.

Duran remains free on bail while his appeal proceeds. The status of the criminal case is now pending the outcome of the appellate review.